Write the Theories Related to Individual and Society

    Home page of MSW papers > Individual and Society

1. Write the Theories Related to Individual and Society

Introduction to Theories on Individual and Society

The relationship between the individual and society is a cornerstone of sociological inquiry, particularly relevant in the Master of Social Work (MSW) course, where understanding this dynamic aids in addressing personal and communal issues. These theories explore how individuals are influenced by social structures and how they, in turn, shape society through actions, interactions, and institutions. Major theories include functionalism, conflict theory, symbolic interactionism, social exchange theory, and contemporary postmodern approaches. Each provides a lens for analyzing human behavior, power dynamics, and social change, offering practical insights for social workers dealing with inequality, identity, and community building. By examining these theories, we can appreciate the tension between individual agency and societal constraints, essential for ethical practice in social work.

Functionalist Theory: Society as a Cohesive System

Functionalism, developed by Emile Durkheim in the late 19th century, portrays society as a stable system where individuals function like parts of a machine to maintain equilibrium. Durkheim's work in "The Division of Labor in Society" (1893) distinguishes between mechanical solidarity in traditional societies, based on similarity, and organic solidarity in modern ones, based on interdependence. Individuals are socialized into roles that contribute to societal needs, such as through family or education, ensuring survival and order. Talcott Parsons expanded this in the 20th century with his AGIL paradigm: Adaptation (economic roles), Goal attainment (political), Integration (social harmony), and Latency (cultural maintenance). For individuals, this means internalizing norms via socialization, preventing deviance. In MSW, functionalism helps explain how disruptions like unemployment lead to anomie, guiding interventions like community programs to restore balance. However, critics like Robert Merton noted manifest (intended) and latent (unintended) functions, acknowledging dysfunctions such as inequality perpetuated by role assignments. This theory emphasizes society's integrative role, but overlooks how individuals resist or innovate beyond prescribed functions.

Conflict Theory: Power Struggles and Inequality

Conflict theory, inspired by Karl Marx's "Communist Manifesto" (1848), views society as a battleground where individuals and groups compete for scarce resources, leading to inequality and change. Marx focused on class conflict between the bourgeoisie (owners) and proletariat (workers), where individuals are alienated from their labor, self, and others. This alienation affects personal identity, fostering false consciousness where workers accept exploitation. Max Weber added layers in "Economy and Society" (1922), incorporating status (prestige) and party (power) alongside class, explaining how individuals navigate multifaceted hierarchies. In contemporary terms, conflict theory applies to gender and racial dynamics, as seen in feminist critiques by Simone de Beauvoir in "The Second Sex" (1949), where women are "othered" by patriarchal structures. For social workers, this theory underscores advocacy, such as in anti-poverty campaigns or labor rights, highlighting how societal structures oppress individuals. Consequences include social revolutions, like the Civil Rights Movement, but the theory is criticized for ignoring cooperation and overemphasizing discord. Ralf Dahrendorf's mid-20th-century extension to authority conflicts in organizations further illustrates how individuals in subordinate roles push for change, relevant in workplace counseling.

Symbolic Interactionism: Meaning-Making Through Interactions

Symbolic interactionism, a micro-level theory from George Herbert Mead's "Mind, Self, and Society" (1934), argues that society emerges from individuals' interpretations of symbols in daily interactions. The self develops through role-taking: the "I" (creative response) and "me" (social expectations). Charles Horton Cooley's "looking-glass self" (1902) adds that individuals see themselves through others' perceptions, shaping identity. Herbert Blumer formalized this with three premises: actions based on meanings, meanings from interactions, and meanings modified through interpretation. In practice, this explains how labels like "deviant" (Howard Becker's "Outsiders," 1963) affect individual behavior, leading to self-fulfilling prophecies. Erving Goffman's "The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life" (1959) uses dramaturgical analysis, viewing life as a stage where individuals perform roles to manage impressions. In MSW, this theory is vital for therapeutic settings, helping clients reframe narratives in cognitive-behavioral therapy or understand stigma in mental health. Limitations include neglecting macro-structures like economic systems, but it empowers individuals as active meaning-makers, fostering empathy in social work practice.

Social Exchange Theory: Rational Choices in Relationships

Social exchange theory, rooted in George Homans' "Social Behavior as Exchange" (1958), treats interactions as transactions where individuals weigh costs and rewards to maximize benefits. Drawing from behavioral psychology, it posits propositions like the success proposition (rewarded behaviors repeat) and value proposition (higher value yields more action). Peter Blau's "Exchange and Power in Social Life" (1964) scales this to macro levels, where unequal exchanges create power imbalances. In relationships, individuals compare alternatives (John Thibaut and Harold Kelley's interdependence theory, 1959), staying if outcomes exceed expectations. This explains phenomena like divorce when costs (emotional strain) outweigh rewards (support). In society, it underlies institutions like markets or politics, where votes are exchanged for policies. For MSW, it informs family dynamics analysis, ensuring balanced exchanges in group therapy, but critics argue it ignores irrational elements like love or altruism. Extensions to equity theory (J. Stacy Adams, 1965) highlight perceptions of fairness, relevant in addressing workplace grievances or community resource distribution.

Postmodern Theories: Fluidity and Deconstruction

Postmodern theories, from thinkers like Michel Foucault and Jean-François Lyotard, challenge meta-narratives, seeing society as fragmented and individuals as constructed through discourses. Foucault's "Discipline and Punish" (1975) introduces power-knowledge, where institutions like prisons shape "docile bodies," influencing individual subjectivity. Jean Baudrillard's "Simulacra and Simulation" (1981) describes hyperreality, where media blurs real and simulated, affecting personal identities in consumer societies. Anthony Giddens' "The Consequences of Modernity" (1990) proposes structuration, where individuals reproduce structures through actions but can reflexively change them. Zygmunt Bauman's "Liquid Modernity" (2000) depicts fluid, uncertain lives, leading to individualized risks. In MSW, these theories address globalization's impact, like migrant identity crises, advocating narrative therapies to deconstruct oppressive discourses. They highlight diversity but are critiqued for relativism, complicating universal ethics in social work.

Additional Perspectives: Feminist and Critical Race Theories

Feminist theory, intersecting with others, examines how gender shapes individual-society relations, as in bell hooks' "Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center" (1984), critiquing patriarchy's marginalization. Critical race theory (Derrick Bell, 1970s) views race as a social construct perpetuating inequality, influencing individual opportunities. These add nuance, essential for culturally competent MSW practice.

Applications in Social Work Practice

In MSW, these theories integrate for eclectic approaches: functionalism for system analysis, conflict for advocacy, interactionism for micro-interventions. Case studies, like helping a homeless individual, involve assessing societal barriers (conflict) and personal meanings (interactionism).

Criticisms and Synthesis

Criticisms include functionalism's conservatism, conflict's pessimism, and interactionism's subjectivism. Synthesis via Pierre Bourdieu's habitus (1977) bridges structure and agency, where individuals internalize social positions but can improvise.

Conclusion: Relevance to Contemporary Society

These theories remain vital in 2025, amid AI and climate challenges, helping social workers promote resilience and justice. Understanding individual-society dynamics fosters transformative practice, empowering both personal growth and societal equity.